
Metal roofing used to mean barns. In the last decade it has become one of the most requested roofs in Marin, the Oakland and Berkeley hills, the Peninsula and anywhere modern architecture lives. Here is an honest look at whether it is worth the price.
The cost math
A standing seam metal roof typically costs two to three times what architectural shingles cost on the same house. It also lasts fifty years or more against twenty five to thirty for shingles. Over the life of the home that is one roof instead of two, plus lower cooling costs from a reflective finish. If you plan to stay, the math usually works. If you plan to sell in five years, it rarely does.
Where it works best
Fire hazard zones, where a noncombustible Class A roof matters for safety and increasingly for insurance. Homes under heavy tree cover, where metal sheds needles and resists moss. Modern and mid century homes, where the clean lines suit the architecture. Low slope roofs that still have enough pitch for a standing seam system.
The myths
Noise: over a solid deck with underlayment, a metal roof is no louder in rain than any other roof. Heat: a light or reflective finish keeps the attic cooler than dark shingles, not hotter. Lightning: it does not attract strikes, and it is safer than wood if struck. Hail: standing seam handles our rare hail far better than shingles.
What to ask
Panel gauge and finish, whether clips are concealed, how the underlayment is rated for heat, how flashing and trim are fabricated, and who has installed metal before. A metal roof installed by a shingle crew with no training is the one metal roof that leaks.
Our take
For the right home and the right owner, metal is the best roof we install. For a 1960s tract home you plan to sell, a quality architectural shingle is the smarter money. We tell you which one you are.
More from the blog

Moss, Redwood Debris and Roof Life in Marin and the Hills
Homes under redwoods and oaks in Marin, Lafayette, Orinda, the Berkeley hills and the Peninsula lose roof years to moisture and debris. How it happens, how to slow it and which materials hold up under canopy.

Preparing Your Roof for the Bay Area Rainy Season
A practical October checklist for homeowners from Marin to San Jose: gutters, valleys, flashing, flat roof drains, attic checks and when to call for an inspection before the first atmospheric river.

7 Signs Your Roof Is Leaking Before You Ever See Water
Most roof leaks run for months before a ceiling stain appears. The seven early warning signs Bay Area homeowners can spot from the ground, the attic and the energy bill.

Request a free roofing quote
Tell us what is going on with your roof and we take it from there. Free inspection, a drone photo report and a written number, usually within a day.
Prefer to pick a day and time? Book online
Get your free roof inspection
Drone photo report included. A few quick questions, about 30 seconds.